Will believers experience shame, grief, remorse at the Bema?
If so, how do we reconcile this with passages like Revelation 7:17, “God shall
wipe away every tear from their eye,” and Revelation 21:4, “and He shall wipe
away every tear from their eyes; and there shall no longer be any death; there
shall no longer be any mourning, or crying, or pain; the first things have
passed away,” or with Isaiah 65:17, “For behold, I create new heavens and a new
earth; And the former things shall not be remembered or come to mind”?
The negative effects involve the following:
(1) The loss suffered in 1 Corinthians 3:15 refers to the
loss of rewards, not salvation as the verse goes on to make clear. Please note
that the clause “he shall suffer loss” would be better rendered “it (the reward)
shall be forfeited.”
(2) The disqualification mentioned in 1 Corinthians 9:27
means disqualified from rewards, not loss of salvation. This is clear from the
context and the analogy to the Greek athletic games.
(3) The “recompense” (NASB) or the “receive back” (KJV) of 2
Corinthians 5:10 refers to the dispensing of rewards or their loss. The verb
used is komizo and means “to carry off safe,” “to carry off as booty.” In the
middle voice as here, it meant “to bear for oneself,”16 or “to receive back what
is one’s own.”17 Compare Matthew 25:27 and Ephesians 6:8.
(4) That dispensing of rewards is in view is also evident
from the Greek words in 2 Corinthians 5:10 translated “good” (agathos—valuable
like good fruit) and “bad” (phaulos—unacceptable like rotten or spoiled fruit).
The idea is not good in the sense of righteousness versus bad in the sense of
evil or sinfulness. For those ideas Paul would have most likely used kalos,
“good,” and kakos, “evil.” For good works, those valuable like good fruit, we
will receive back rewards, but for bad works, those rotten and worthless, we
will receive no rewards or the loss of rewards.
This is no more a punishment than when a student turns in a
worthless assignment and receives an F or a D. His poor work results in a just
grade or recompense. This is what his work deserves. There used to be a sign in
the registrar’s office at Dallas Seminary which read, “Salvation is by grace …
Graduation is by works.”
(5) 1 John 2:28. This verse undoubtedly refers to the Bema
and shows there will be both boldness as a result of abiding, and shame before
the Lord as a result of failing to abide.
“And now little children.” John is writing to believers. This
is his term of endearment for his readers as born again people.
“Abide in Him.” “Abide” is a synonym for fellowship which is
the subject of the book (1:3-7). It means to remain in Him from the standpoint
of drawing on His life as the source of ours and then to obey Him out of that
relationship of dependence. This is the basis of rewards or the cause of their
loss, the abiding, Christ-dependent life.
“So that” points us to the purpose, the return of the Savior
and what it will mean.
“When He appears.” The “when” points to the imminency of the
return of the Lord. It is literally “if He appears.” The conditional clause does
not question the reality of Christ’s coming, only the time of it and thereby
points to its imminency. “Appears” refers to the rapture which leads quickly
into the Bema.
“We may have confidence.” “Confidence” is parrhesia and means
“courage, boldness to speak.” Point: Though none of us are perfect or ever will
be, still, faithfulness to abide and obey the Lord will give confidence of
rewards.
“And not shrink away from Him in shame at His coming
(presence).” Please note several things here. (a) The verb is what we call in
Greek an aorist subjunctive, and with the basic meaning of this verb, the
grammar points to a future act, but not a continuous state. This in no way
suggests a permanent condition. (b) The voice of the verb is passive. The
subject receives the action, that is, he is made to feel shame. But how? (c)
There are two views:
(1) The believer who fails to abide is made to feel shame by
the Lord, i.e., the Lord puts him to shame. This would be somewhat punitive and
does not fit the concept of the Bema nor the promises of the Lord that we will
not come into judgment.
(2) The believer who fails to abide experiences shame by the
revelatory nature of Christ’s presence at the Bema. This is caused by the
realization of what his own failure and sin has cost him in terms of the loss of
rewards and loss of glory to the Lord. But this will only be momentary or
short-lived at best in view of passages like Revelation 7:17; 21:4 and Isaiah
65:17. [To be
concluded]