[faithandlife] A Premature Announcement?

Message: < previous - next > : Reply : Subscribe : Cleanse
Home   : June 2007 : Group Archive : Group : All Groups

From: charles scott <crscottblu@...>
Date: Tue, 12 Jun 2007 21:00:19 -0700 (PDT)
Fr Wiebe+

I suspect that it was Ephraim Radner who wrote this
tortured bit of prose.

http://anglicancommunioninstitute.com/content/view/87/1

He sounds a mite less hopeful than he did in 2004 when
his "Hope Among the Fragments" was published.  In Part
I of that book he argues "the Virtue of Staying Put."

Five years ago, some of our brothers wondered aloud
whether it was better for the orthodox to stay in TEC
and work for reform or to come out and build anew. 
That was before the Titanic entered its final plunge
into the depths.  Now it appears there will be few
conservatives remaining to sing "Nearer my God to
Thee."

I like some of the points that Radner makes in his
books, but I have to wonder if anyone other than
scholars read his offerings.

Ernest Hemingway said that he found it difficult to
write more than 250 words a day. As I read one of
Radner's more opaque chapters, I thought of writing
styles and of Hemingway's saying.  I proceded to count
just 3 of Radner's convoluted sentences and found that
the sentences averaged 90 words.  In just 3 sentences 
he passed Heminway's daily output.

"Hope Among the fragments has 234 pages.  If we
subtract from that number 14 title pages, introduction
and otherwise shortened pages, we come up with 220
pages with 39 lines to the page and an average of 11
words to the line.  Give or take a few, the sum total
of words is 94,000.  Radner refers to the tragedy of
Sept 11, 2001 in the book.  Assuming that he began
work on the book sometime after 911, and completed it
in early 2004, he likely spent less than two years in
the writing.  

Doing the math, it appears he was clipping along at a
faster rate than Hemingway, with much more involved
plot lines and words and concepts that were
considerably more weighty. Radner is the master of
packing polysyllabic words into a phrase.

His voice should have been heard.  His 11th hour plea
in the Anglican Institute Article should be taken to
heart by the leaders of the Anglican Communion and the
TEC.

The problem is, few will hack their way through the
dense growth of verbiage. It is doubtful that there
are many in his intended audience who have "ears to
hear" his message.

There may have been, or may still may be "Hope Among
the Fragments".  However, a translator is needed.

Charles+

"--------------------------------



--- "The Rev GDVWiebe SSC.,PhD" <gdvw@...>
wrote:

> >
> > Brothers+
> > Sounds like an essay I read aeons ago in a volume
> on Victorian
> England-and look what happened. I suspect that in
> another few years we
> will look back and ask why we did (collectively that
> is) not have a bit
> more faith in what we are about.  Then it was
> Tractarian-Oxford-Anglo
> Catholicism. Today it is FIFUK. Blessings. GDVW+
> (Please pray for
> Randall Davis dying of Stage 4 cancer).
> 
>"========================== 
> 
> > Near the end of a lengthy article the principals
> of the Anglican Communion Institute ruminate about>
the end of the Anglican Communion.
> >
http://anglicancommunioninstitute.com/content/view/87/1
> > Charles+