[pastorsforum] Re: [PastorsForum] Calvinism vs. Arminianism

Message: < previous - next > : Reply : Subscribe : Cleanse
Home   : June 2006 : Group Archive : Group : All Groups

From: "Kevin Sigafoos" <ksigafoos@...>
Date: Wed, 14 Jun 2006 09:44:39 -0400
On 6/14/06, Bill burns <burnswh@...> wrote:
> I think God does value "free will" more than His children.  Why, He wants us
> to come to Him freely and to strive to be more Christ-like freely.  If He
> wanted us to do otherwise He would have made robots.  God doesnt want
> robots!!
>

So, Bill, when women are raped, children are brutally abused, men
suffer horrible accidents, and puppies are drowned ... does God sit
idly by whistling to Himself "hmm hmm hmm I could step in and fix that
but free-will ya' know ... wouldn't want to interfere."  Is that your
idea of a loving God?  If this is your conception of God's involvement
in our lives than what sense can you possibly make out of Rom 8:28?

Is libertarian free-will a sufficient enough "good" in itself to
justify a world where all of the pain and suffering in this world
vastly outweighs the good?  Would not a wise God choose to create only
if He were confident that substantive moral good would be secure?  How
can he do that if He isn't "acquainted with all of our steps?" (Psa
139:3)

If God creates us with the power to go against His plan, then is it
not entirely possible that evil will prevail over good?  How can God
guarantee that His good purposes will prevail?  Did Jesus go to the
cross only "hoping" that maybe someone will wake up and choose Him?
Would God send His Son to die on a "hope and a prayer?"  That would be
pretty risky, would it not?  Considering that no one seeks after God
and that we all have turned to our own way, that's a very foolish risk
to take.

Also, Bill, will we have the same freedom in heaven?  After all, God
wouldn't want "robots" worshipping Him in heaven, right?  If so, that
how will believers live sinlessly for eternity while retaining
libertarian freedom?  Either they can and may sin, in which case
eternal life cannot be promised with certainty, or they do no have
libertarian freedom and so cannot sin, but neither, then, according to
your definition, can they love and worship God

Predestination glorifies God -- it does not make us robots.

-- 


Grace and peace,
Kevin Sigafoos
---------------------
For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be
glory forever. Amen. (Rom 11:36)